Cuba Protects its Children and Enforces Law
By Istvan Ojeda Bello
Children are the most important members for any family and most states have shown concern for the wellbeing of future generations. Consequently, if parents fail to fulfill their natural obligations, it is the responsibility for the nation’s judicial power to take measures to preserve the integrity of its youngest citizens.
The Convention on the Rights of the Child, adopted by the UN General Assembly in 1989 and in effect since 1990, clearly expresses in its ninth article that "state parties shall ensure that a child not be separated from his or her parents against their will, except when competent authorities —subject to judicial review— determine, in accordance with applicable law and procedures, that such separation is necessary for the best interests of the child."
Currently 96 percent of the children around the world, including Cuban children, live in countries whose laws are compatible with the UN convention. The right of parents to raise their children, regardless of their religious or political beliefs, has been recognized worldwide.
Spain’s constitution, for instance, states in its 39th article that parents should provide all types of assistance to children they have had within or outside marriage, while they are minors and in other cases that the law may establish.
Likewise, Mexico’s constitution affirms in Article 4 that parents shall ensure the right of minors to satisfy their needs and must take care for their physical and mental health.
Guatemala’s Magna Carta makes it clear, in Article 51, that "the state shall ensure the physical, mental, and moral wellbeing of minors and the elderly. It will ensure their right to food, healthcare, education and security, and welfare."
The obligations established by the different national laws even consider the possibility of withdrawing the legal custody of minors from people who are a threat to the physical or mental integrity of children. It is therefore not at all strange that several countries include in their fundamental legislation the commitment of the state to the welfare of boys and girls.
In that sense Germany’s constitution, in Article 6, states that "the protection and education of children is a natural right entitled to parents and an obligation which primarily involves them (…) children could only be separated from their family by virtue of a law, if those in responsible for their education do not comply with their duties, or if, for others reason, the children run the risk of abandonment." It is an outrageous crime to cause any harm to a child.
That is why judicial institutions are very severe with those who mistreat children. Recently a Catalonian court withdrew the custody of their four children from a couple who lives Barcelona. They were accused of maltreatment and neglect after one of their children had to be operated on for necrosis in one of his hands; this had resulted from a poorly treated burn. The mother was the first to be arrested. Due to the resulting lesions, she was accused of child neglect, which is considered a crime by Article 226 of the Spanish Penal Code.
In Valencia, also in Spain, some 70 parents lost their rights to their children in 2005 after judicial authorities proved that the minors were living in a dangerous family situation. The Constitution of the Republic of Cuba, in its fourth chapter, recognizes that the family is the fundamental unit of society and states that parents have the duties to feed their children, assist them in the defense of their interests, and contribute actively to their education and development.
Cuba has proven on several occasions its attachment to the right of parents to give their children the type of education that they consider most appropriate, even prior to the UN adoption of the Convention on the Rights of the Child. Perhaps the period which was most trying for Cuba was in the 1960’s, when many parents —confused by counter-revolutionary propaganda— sent their children alone to the US.
In September 1961, Fidel Castro, who was then prime minister of the revolutionary government, said, "It is painful that those children are being sent there [to the US] to be educated, but above all, we respect the sentiment and right of each family." Those were the days of Operation Peter Pan, a slanderous propaganda campaign directed from the US which spread the rumor that the Cuban government would deprive parents of custody of their children.
More than 14,000 children were taken to the US. The revolutionary government, however, never prevented the departure of any of the minors, as long as they left the country in a safe and legal manner. According to Dr. Olga Miranda Bravo, if the authorities had prevented the departure of the children —whom their parents had given the corresponding authorization through a notarial act and all requirements for travel abroad had been met— then the slanderer would have been proven right.
Miaranda Bravo, who has been a member of The Hague’s Permanent Court of Arbitration since 1973 and an adjunct Professor of Havana’s Higher Institute of International Relations, says that, "child custody, according to Cuban legislation, is a right of all parents, even those who are not disqualified to exercise it.
This was not the case of those parents misled by that propaganda, as they excised their right and transferred it to US authorities or to their representatives in that country. For that, they subsequently paid a high price, as in many cases they lost their children, were later rebuked by their children or by history itself. Laws have acknowledged that parents have the right to raise their children and to take them wherever they decide.
But the laws in most countries around the world have also established that parents cannot violate the laws, nor are they entitled to put the lives of their children at stake


